Tarrytown vs. Barton Hills: Austin's Two Finest Urban Luxury Neighborhoods Compared

78703 vs. 78704 Buyer Guide  ·  May 2026

Tarrytown and Barton Hills are the two most debated luxury neighborhoods in Austin for one reason: they are both genuinely excellent, and choosing between them is not obvious. Different zip codes, different characters, different lifestyles — but the same buyer profile arrives at both shortlists regularly. This is the comparison that actually helps you decide.

Call (512) 608-8811 Search Austin Luxury Listings

Tarrytown sits in northwest Austin — 78703 — between Lake Austin to the west and MoPac to the east, roughly 1.5 miles from downtown. It is one of Austin's oldest established luxury neighborhoods, with a residential character shaped by decades of careful stewardship and an almost complete absence of vacant buildable land. The homes here range from meticulously preserved 1920s and 1930s architecture to fully custom modern renovations on the same generous lots that have sat in the same families for generations.

Barton Hills sits in southwest Austin — 78704 — abutting the Barton Creek Greenbelt, roughly 2.5 miles from downtown. It is Austin's most active luxury new construction submarket, a neighborhood in visible transformation as boutique builders deliver $2.5M–$4M spec homes on lots that were occupied by mid-century ranches a few years before. The energy here is forward-looking rather than historical, and the lifestyle it delivers is anchored by Greenbelt access and Barton Springs proximity rather than architectural heritage.

Same city. Same buyer income bracket. Genuinely different places to live — and the right answer depends entirely on which version of Austin luxury life you are buying into.

The Character Distinction: Established Prestige vs. Active Urban Luxury

The single most important dimension to understand before comparing prices and schools and walkability scores is the character distinction between these two neighborhoods. It is not a quality distinction — both are genuinely excellent. It is a lifestyle and aesthetic distinction, and getting it right at the outset saves time on both sides of the search.

Tarrytown has the quiet confidence of a neighborhood that has been luxury for a very long time. The streets are narrow and heavily canopied. The homes sit on generous lots behind mature landscaping. There is an unhurried, understated quality to the neighborhood that reflects its age and the stability of its resident base. Walkers and cyclists are the transportation mode. The commercial amenities nearby — the West 6th Street and Clarksville dining corridor, the nearby grocery and coffee options — are walkable and locally-owned in character. Lake Austin Boulevard connects residents to the lake and the trail system at the western edge of the neighborhood.

Barton Hills has the energy of a neighborhood mid-transformation. New construction is visible. Builder trucks park on streets where ranches are being demolished and replaced. The architectural vocabulary is contemporary — dark cedar, black steel windows, exposed concrete — and the neighborhood is being actively redefined by the product being delivered on its blocks. The lifestyle here centers on the Greenbelt trail system, Barton Springs Pool, and the South Austin urban corridor. It is more eclectic, more visually dynamic, and more obviously in motion than Tarrytown.

Neither is a criticism of the other. Buyers who want established, stable, quiet, historically-grounded luxury will feel at home in Tarrytown in a way they may not in Barton Hills. Buyers who want to be in a neighborhood at the leading edge of Austin's luxury new construction market, surrounded by the city's most active outdoor lifestyle amenities, belong in Barton Hills.

Price and What You Get: The Direct Comparison

The pattern is consistent: Barton Hills delivers more finished square footage per dollar at every price tier. Tarrytown delivers more lot character, established canopy, and proximity to Lake Austin at a slightly lower per-SF price point. Buyers who are optimizing for the newest possible construction with the most modern finishes will find the Barton Hills new build market a better fit. Buyers who are optimizing for lot quality, architectural character, and the specific lifestyle of a Lake Austin-adjacent neighborhood will find the Tarrytown premium well-justified.

Schools: Both Are AISD — But the Campus Matters

Both Tarrytown and Barton Hills fall within Austin ISD, which is an important starting point — neither neighborhood benefits from the Eanes ISD premium that drives much of Westlake's pricing. But the within-AISD quality distinction is meaningful enough to address directly.

Tarrytown feeds primarily to Casis Elementary, which is consistently ranked among the top elementary campuses in Austin ISD. Casis is a genuine differentiator within the district — families who are prioritizing public school quality within Austin and do not want to pay the Eanes ISD premium will find Tarrytown's elementary assignment meaningfully stronger than most AISD options. The middle and high school assignments for Tarrytown follow O. Henry Middle School and Austin High School, both of which are among the better secondary campuses in the district.

Barton Hills elementary assignments vary by block and are more heterogeneous than Tarrytown's. Some Barton Hills blocks feed to Barton Hills Elementary, which is a strong campus. Others feed to different assignments depending on street location. For buyers where public elementary school quality is a meaningful decision variable, Tarrytown's more consistent Casis assignment is a genuine differentiator. For buyers using private schools or who do not have school-age children, this dimension largely disappears from the comparison.

Lifestyle: Lake Austin vs. the Greenbelt

The lifestyle division between these two neighborhoods runs along the water — and it is a meaningful difference that buyers who are relocating from outside Austin sometimes underestimate.

Tarrytown's western edge abuts Lake Austin Boulevard, putting residents within walking or biking distance of Lake Austin and the trail system that runs along its north shore. This is a different amenity from Barton Springs — Lake Austin is a reservoir on the Colorado River, accessible by kayak and paddleboard from public access points, with a more tranquil, shaded character than the bustling Zilker Park environment. The lifestyle it supports is quieter and more contemplative than the high-energy, high-density Barton Springs scene.

Barton Hills delivers the Greenbelt and Barton Springs combination detailed in our companion Barton Springs post — a spring-fed pool, miles of limestone creek trail, and a year-round outdoor culture that is uniquely Austin in character. Buyers for whom the Greenbelt morning run and the Barton Springs afternoon swim are defining lifestyle anchors will find Barton Hills the more intentional address.

Both lifestyles center on Austin's extraordinary natural amenities. They are not interchangeable, and the buyer who has actually visited both and spent time in each neighborhood usually knows which one they belong in before they have seen a single home.

New Construction Availability

This is the dimension where the two neighborhoods diverge most dramatically — and it is a dimension that matters enormously to a specific category of buyer.

Barton Hills has one of the most active luxury new construction pipelines of any neighborhood inside Austin city limits. The teardown and infill cycle has been running for years and continues to deliver boutique luxury spec homes at $2.5M–$4M+ with the modern architecture and full-luxury specifications that buyers moving from coastal markets expect. If your priority is buying a newly completed home — with builder warranties, contemporary design, and the ability to move in without touching anything — Barton Hills is the better submarket.

Tarrytown has virtually no new construction. The combination of established development patterns, heritage tree coverage, and compatibility standards that protect the neighborhood's character has effectively closed Tarrytown to the teardown-and-rebuild cycle that drives Barton Hills. What new construction exists in Tarrytown is extraordinarily rare — perhaps a handful of projects per year — and it commands a significant premium when it surfaces precisely because of its scarcity.

For buyers who specifically want new construction and are not attached to a particular neighborhood, Barton Hills is the answer. For buyers who are open to a well-executed renovation and value the character of an older home on an established lot, Tarrytown opens up a product type that Barton Hills increasingly cannot offer.

The Side-by-Side: All Variables at a Glance

Who Belongs in Tarrytown

Tarrytown is the right answer when you want to be as close to downtown as Austin's luxury residential market allows, the character and age of the housing stock is part of the appeal rather than a liability, Lake Austin proximity and the West Austin lifestyle corridor matter to how you will live daily, and you are open to finding the right renovated or character-preserved older home rather than requiring new construction. It is also the right answer for buyers with school-age children who want the best available Austin ISD elementary assignment without paying the Eanes ISD premium.

The appreciation thesis for Tarrytown is the strongest in the Austin luxury market. Buyers who are weighing the financial dimension of this decision alongside the lifestyle dimension will find the Tarrytown supply constraint argument compelling — there is simply no path to new supply here, and demand is not declining. For buyers who plan to hold for 7–10 years, that arithmetic is difficult to argue with.

Who Belongs in Barton Hills

Barton Hills is the right answer when you specifically want new construction with contemporary architecture and full luxury specifications, the Greenbelt trail system and Barton Springs proximity are defining lifestyle priorities, you want a broader range of options including off-market and pre-market new builds, and the eclectic, forward-looking energy of a neighborhood in active transformation appeals rather than concerns you. The buyer who has spent time in Barton Hills and walked the Greenbelt and swum at Barton Springs usually does not need more convincing — the neighborhood sells itself on lifestyle in a way that is difficult to describe to someone who has not experienced it.

For buyers coming from New York, San Francisco, or Los Angeles who want the most urban, lifestyle-rich residential experience Austin offers, Barton Hills consistently wins the comparison. The combination of new construction quality, outdoor amenity access, and proximity to South Austin's restaurant and cultural corridor delivers a daily life that coastal buyers recognize and respond to.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which neighborhood is more walkable?
Both score well by Austin standards, but they offer different kinds of walkability. Tarrytown is walkable to Lake Austin Boulevard, the nearby dining and grocery options on 35th Street and West 6th, and the surrounding residential streets. Barton Hills is walkable to the Greenbelt trail system, Barton Springs Pool, and South Congress via a longer walk or short bike ride. If downtown walkability is the priority, Tarrytown wins on raw distance. If nature and outdoor amenity walkability is the priority, Barton Hills wins.

Are there off-market opportunities in Tarrytown the way there are in Barton Hills?
Yes, though the mechanism is different. In Barton Hills, off-market activity is driven by the builder and developer network — teardown sellers going direct to builder buyers. In Tarrytown, off-market activity is driven by seller discretion — long-term homeowners who want to sell privately without public listing disruption. The Davis Agency maintains relationships in both communities and surfaces off-market opportunities in Tarrytown when they arise, though the volume is lower than in Barton Hills given the overall lower transaction frequency.

Is there any new construction in Tarrytown worth considering?
Occasionally, yes. A handful of projects per year — typically on lots that have been acquired through estate sales or from long-term owners — produce new construction in Tarrytown that commands a significant premium precisely because of its rarity. When new construction surfaces in Tarrytown, it moves quickly and typically off-market before it reaches MLS. If new construction in Tarrytown is something you would consider, having an agent with relationships in the neighborhood is how you access those opportunities.

How do the property tax rates compare between 78703 and 78704?
Both zip codes are inside Austin city limits and fall within Austin ISD, so the tax structure is essentially the same. Both pay Austin city taxes, Travis County taxes, and Austin ISD taxes. The effective rate difference between the two is minimal — within the same 1.8–2.2% effective rate range depending on assessed value, exemptions, and protest history. Neither carries a meaningful tax advantage over the other.

Which neighborhood has stronger appreciation potential going forward?
On pure appreciation trajectory, Tarrytown's 4–6% projected rate for 2026 is higher than Barton Hills' more stable baseline. The supply exhaustion driving Tarrytown's appreciation is structural rather than cyclical, which suggests the outperformance is durable rather than a short-term phenomenon. That said, Barton Hills' active new construction cycle and broad national buyer pool provide a form of liquidity and demand depth that Tarrytown's lower transaction volume cannot match. Both are strong holds. Tarrytown has the higher appreciation ceiling; Barton Hills has the more liquid market.